Overall Rating


FirstMerit Bank Report Card

Overall rating score 37%
Customer Rating
Financial Health
Bank Fees
Number of Locations
Mobile Banking

Branch Locations

FirstMerit Bank Location Map
We found branches close to you.

Add a Bank to Compare

Bank Reviews
CIT Bank
Bank Rates
Susquehanna Bank
Bank Reviews
Bny Mellon, National Association
Compare Banks

FirstMerit Bank Customer Reviews

Customer Service
Bank Rates
Online Experience
Fees & Charges
Overall Satisfaction
Post a review

FirstMerit Bank Latest Customer Reviews

oldwoodsman's Profile Image

Reviewed by oldwoodsman

Apr 7th 2014

1 out of 5 marks

Fees / Fees / Fees.. Talked down as talking to a child.

I moved to this bank due to the location from work and home. I did review fees and other important info. going back over this past yr I have spent little over $550 in fees alone. This morning as I deposited some in checking I was advised of $10 for statement form.. which I only do online statements(?) and fees non-merit bank activity. never had this before. so with alone they charged me $35 addition because I was overdrawn. I talked to admin, but was talked to as a child. I have been given fees to go negative so I could be charged again for being overdrawn.. I have never had so much trouble with a bank.. Its all about the money, not the little guy.

I'm pulling my $50k and going back to my old bank..

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 1 ▼ No 0

firstmerithorrible's Profile Image

Reviewed by firstmerithorrible

Apr 4th 2014

1 out of 5 marks


I'm not going to waste a ton more time explaining the whole situation, but if you are considering banking with First Merit, DO NOT. The branches are okay (depending on your branch of course) but they don't have any authority. All the authority goes through Ohio, and they could care less about their customers other than the $ signs. This is the most paranoid bank I've ever run across, constantly calling to verify if you've actually made transactions. Constantly asking you how you are spending your money. Requiring incredibly tedious log in verification, etc.

It's too bad too because Citizens was a good bank before they bought them. The whole switchover from Citizens was a disaster too. Choose literally any other bank and you'll be happier.

It's such a pain to switch banks, but they've aggravated me to the point that I have to.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 1 ▼ No 0

CommonSenseGuy2's Profile Image

Reviewed by CommonSenseGuy2

Mar 24th 2014

2 out of 5 marks

Do NOT get a mortgage through First Merit Bank!

We are not new to mortgages, by any means. As we enjoy our local branch of First Merit Bank, we were curious to see about refinancing our mortgage.

Our mortgage contact in Bolingbrook, IL was the worst from the start. She would rarely return our calls, (but needed everything on her end "right away!") didn't show up for the closing... didn't let us know that the title company wasn't coming either, so we showed up and waited for more than an hour... for nothing. She even lied about our numbers to "get the load through". I wrote to the President and he actually sent me back an insulting, 3 page letter defending her! Yes, the President of the Mortgage Company!

Fine.. She lied. The President doesn't care because he got our business. We got a ridiculously low rate... and that's what we wanted. Lesson learned.

That was in the past (2013)... Now for YET ANOTHER BAD SURPRISE...Because our First Merit Mortgage person "fudged numbers" on our loan, we just got a letter (March 2014) stating our escrow account is about $2,000 short (about 6 months of taxes she left out of the original documents which was part of the lie I wrote the President about!) and that our payment just went up by $150 a month. (about a 16.5% increase in our monthly payment!)

20 years of mortgages, including 3 refinanced, and we have NEVER been more than about $100-$200 short on escrow. But we've never dealt with this corrupt group before, either.

While I'd recommend our local branch for everyday "personal banking" because of the people there, I'd suggest RUNNING from ANY mortgage pitch from First Merit Bank.

If the mortgage person can lie about the numbers and the President of the Mortgage Group defends her actions without even speaking to us, and then the CUSTOMER gets screwed.... WHY... WHY on God's green earth would you want to go with such a shady mortgage department?

Yes... find another mortgage company. No matter who else you go with, you'll be glad you did.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 2 ▼ No 0

ddaczyk's Profile Image

Reviewed by ddaczyk

Mar 19th 2014

1 out of 5 marks

ddaczyk 3/19/14 poor online cust. serv.

The people in customer serv. ( mobile banking)seem to have the attitude that they are talking to someone that knows absolutely nothing. Their attitude seems to be that they are far more superior than the customer. It should have stayed Citizens First. The local bank people are very good with customer serv. The corporate customer serv. needs an attitude adjustment.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 1 ▼ No 0

unhappywithFirstMe's Profile Image

Reviewed by unhappywithFirstMe

Feb 27th 2014

1 out of 5 marks

terrible customer service ever since they became First Merit. Thinking about switching

We have been extremely unhappy with First Merit ever since Citizens changed to First Merit. Additional procedures are inconvenient, online system is worse and not user-friendly, waiting times for deposits are worse. If it continues to go downhill, we will definitely be changing banks. It was funny when I pointed out the sign at the counter stating that you will notice no changes once we switch to First Merit and it will be seamless. They seem to care more about their procedures than their customers now. It didn't used to be that way with Citizens Bank.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 2 ▼ No 0

Post a review

Sumit your question by creating a free account

Already a member?