Overall Rating

MyBankTracker Grade

Customer Rating
Financial Health
Bank Fees
Bank Rates
Number of Locations
Mobile Banking

Featured Rates

Branch Locations

First Niagara Bank Location Map
We found branches close to you.

Add a Bank to Compare

Bank News
CIT Bank
Bank News
Hudson City Bank
Bank Rates
First Republic Bank
Compare Banks

First Niagara Bank Customer Review

Post a review
Hreeso's Profile Image

1 out of 5 marks

Reviewed by Hreeso

Jul 3rd 2012

The Worse Bank I Have Ever Done Business With. I Have Been There For Over 9 Years, And Am Leaving Next Month.

When i looked at my account on line on 7/3/12 in the morning everything was fine. I got home from work and looked on line again, and it revealed that two checks came in that same day, on 7/3/12, causing two overdrafts. A cash deposit was made on the same day at around 12:30 in the afternoon.. I still incurred $70 in nsf fees.

They are not logical people, they do not care about their customers, it doesn't matter how long you've been with their institution. They are fee happy, and they are going to lose many customers if they choose to continue this way. I am moving all my accounts. My business account usually has monthly deposits of around $15 to 20k, they don't care. I am out of there by next month, and i can't wait.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 2 ▼ No 0

Other First Niagara Bank Reviews

joonieboony's Profile Image

Reviewed by joonieboony

Oct 13th 2014

1 out of 5 marks

Worst Bank I Ever Met

1. Cheated on my money for 250 dollar, cash back program

2. Make an appointment but never show up.

3. Make mistake for type of saving account and over charge me.

4. I change type for checking account from plus to normal, but never response. Then i close account then :) in the end.


Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 1 ▼ No 0

davedsel's Profile Image

Reviewed by davedsel

Oct 6th 2014

1 out of 5 marks

The Worst Bank I Have Ever Dealth With

Last year we refinanced our auto loan to First Niagara Bank and our eldest son refinanced his auto loan to there as well. Every month his payment was posted to our account and a late charge was added. There is no electronics funds transfer from the bank we have our checking accounts with and FNB.

Every month a paper check was cut and sent. The loan processing department at FNB would manually write the full account number on each check, putting our account number on both our check and our son's check. Every month I would have to call and they would straighten it out. I was told it was my fault because our bank's bill pay did not put the full account number on the check, just the last four digits. I had automatic monthly payments set up with no ability to add a note or menu. I would have had to manually initiate a payment each month to get the full account number on the check.

Finally we refinanced in September. Our loan was payed off about two weeks ago, but our sons was not. After many exasperating calls to customer service and my wife sending a negative review on their website, our son's loan was paid off today and the last late charge reversed, but there is still a small balance because they did not post the check in a timely manner. I am hoping they will write off that small amount and close the loan.

This should have never happened with today's available technology. Customer service was not always courteous or helpful, and I usually spent 20-30 minutes on the phone with them each month to resolve their mistakes.

I worked in banking for 20 years for two other local banks. This is inexcusable and not an incentive to ever bank with First Niagara Bank for any reason ever. I had to click on one star for this review, but wish I did not have to click on any. FNB deserves no stars and really needs to review their loan processing systems and procedures.

Is this review helpful? ▲ Yes 1 ▼ No 0

Post a review View all Reviews