Online Bill Pay Finds Enemy in Credit Cards

Simon Zhen

By  Updated on Wed Feb 15, 2012

Simon Zhen is an analyst, staff writer and columnist for MyBankTracker.com. His columns draw focus to all aspects of personal finance and to bank rates, products, and services. More Columns »

Online Bill Pay Finds Enemy in Credit Cards

Chelsea Oakes / Flickr source

The tube is swarming with banks urging you to pay utilities, creditors and retailers through banks’ online bill pay systems. But the allure is less than remarkable  — there are more  lucrative rewards and more numerous perks to using a credit card.

Banks’ online bill pay is more convenient than writing checks. It’s more friendly to the environment. It consolidates bills at a single bank account.

Yet, like many other American consumers, I don’t really use my bank’s online bill pay feature.

And I believe the biggest reason that online bill pay doesn’t get much attention is: credit cards.

Utilities and telecommunication services usually accept bill payments through a credit card. But if  your credit card bill is paid off every month, it is smarter to use a cash back or rewards credit card to pay any household bills.

Simply set up automatic payments to cut down on the time spent managing the bills — but remember to take a few seconds to review the statements every month.

Additionally, paying with credit cards is often regarded as safer than paying with debit cards and the checking accounts to which they’re linked.

In a recent comScore report, 43% of respondents cited security concerns for not using online bill pay in 2011. Concerns were likely influenced by recent security breaches at Sony, Michaels Stores and Zappos, which made consumers wary about disclosing information to merchants and retailers.

In the unlikely event that a company leaks sensitive customer information, would it be worse for thieves to steal your credit-card number or your bank account number (which can be found at the bottom of checks that are sent via online bill pay)?

If it were me, I’d certainly prefer a slip-up to occur with my credit card, because it is easier to get a new credit-card number than a new bank account number.

And the little things

It’s not just credit cards that pose a hurdle to widespread adoption of online bill pay.

The comScore report found that 25 percent of respondents like to receive monthly reminders in email, another 11 percent said online bill pay was too complicated, while 8 percent felt that setting up accounts was too time-consuming.

Online bill pay may also take longer because the feature will sometimes print checks, which are then sent to payees. When the payment needs to be processed in a hurry, a paper check may not make the due date.

With the rise in financial tech innovations, I won’t be surprised if a middle man comes in to fill the gap by connecting major service providers and banks – making online bill pay easier to understand and use.

And to make the feature even more attractive, banks should reward customers for using online bill pay!

Related
 

Post a Comment

  • Pdgibbons

    I 95% of my bills on-line, through my bank’s on-line bill-pay site. It is extremely easy and secure and takes very little time. All but one of my regular bills has a relationship with my bank and the money is directly deposited into their accounts — there is no paper check, no exposed bank account number or routing number, nothing to breach security. Plus, if there were any “slip-ups”, I can walk into my local branch and speak with a manager to get it fixed. Also, many of the “rewards” offered through credit cards are never used, and those that are used may be taxable.

    • http://www.mybanktracker.com Simon Zhen

      Well, online bill pay appears to better fit your habits. I use my cash back credit cards for everything so the earnings from a year full of bills can really stack up.

      Note: credit card rewards or cash back, that are received from spending, are not taxable.

  • VinnyAnand

    I agree with Pdgibbons; in today’s world of banking Bills On-Line are electronically transferred to the receiving party. This is usually done via an ACH submission or another wire transfer mechanism depending on the relationship with the Billers’s bank account. 

    1. If your banks send checks via mail to the Biller, time for you to move to another bank that does so in a secure fashion electronically. Most major banks offer this service with 2 business days of payment to the biller as a promise.

    2. There is currently a debate underway (started between IRS and CitiGroup) wherein “rewards” will be deemed taxable. This was driven by a promotion to offer some miles on American Airlines. CitiGroup has already sent tax statement to the consumers that have bought the “reward” as part of the incentive to receive the card.

    3. Please also not that a number of Utility companies (Gas, Water, Electricity) only offer now Bill On-Line or check to pay for bills. This is driven by the high cost charged by credit card companies to process the payment

    4. I have used Wells Fargo, Bank of America and Chase in the past 5 years. The set-up process for a new biller is simple and executing the transaction only takes a few seconds; unless you have a terrible internet connection – which might hold good for any website you surf.