We get it. Not everyone can get (or wants) a traditional checking account or credit card. But, in this day and age, you still need to swipe. Right? That’s why prepaid cards exist.
Why you should get a prepaid card:
- You have difficulty getting a checking account or credit card.
- You need a debit card for online and mobile shopping.
- You want to avoid overdrafts and/or minimize spending.
Why you shouldn’t get a prepaid card:
- You are capable of getting a free checking account or credit card.
- Your favorite celebrity or TV personality was advertising the prepaid card.
Prepaid cards offer an easy entry into the world of non-cash payments. No credit check or bank account needed. However, there are way too many options available in the market today — how do you know which prepaid card to get? We selected the best prepaid debit cards that are worth considering by examining the fees and customer experiences. After analyzing the key advantages and disadvantages of these cards, these are MyBankTracker’s top recommendations:
American Express Serve
With the American Express Serve prepaid card, you may be able to avoid the majority of fees that are often found with other prepaid cards. It has a $1 monthly fee ($0 in NY, TX and VT), which can be waived with direct deposit, $500 loaded per month or by linking the card to the Softcard (formerly known as Isis mobile wallet –a free mobile app). So, simply add the card to Softcard and you’re going to avoid the fee.
The card is free when you sign up online (or you can buy it at retail locations and pay up to $3.95). Loading cash is free through direct deposit, cash reload at select retailers (i.e., CVS, Family Dollar, Walmart and 7-Eleven), transfer from a deposit account, a debit card or mobile check deposit. Additionally, there is no fee for withdrawing cash through any MoneyPass ATM (an ATM network with more than 24,000 ATMs nationwide and at retailers like Walmart — find one near you). All other ATM withdrawals cost $2 each.
It is relatively easy to avoid the sign-up fee and the monthly fee. You cannot go wrong with the American Express Serve card.
- Pros: Easy-to-avoid monthly fee and plenty of free cash load options
- Cons: Requires compatible smartphone
H&R Block Emerald Prepaid MasterCard
For many prepaid cards, the fixed monthly costs amount to a sizable chunk of expenses. The H&R Block Emerald Prepaid MasterCard is one of the few prepaid cards that doesn’t charge a monthly fee or an activation fee.
There are no fees for direct deposits, incoming and external bank transfers, card transactions and telephone customer service. You’ll pay fees for things like ATM withdrawals ($2.50 per cash withdrawal), cash reloads at retail locations and using online bill pay.
Essentially, with this card, you are paying depending on your usage of the card — there are no fixed monthly costs. If you just use it for swiping and online shopping, it is possible to not incur any service fees at all.
- Pros: No monthly fee or activation fee
- Cons: Fees for activity such as ATM withdrawals, cash reloads and bill pay
Green Dot Prepaid Debit Card
For typical cash reloads on prepaid cards, your only option is to purchase a cash reload card from certain stores. Green Dot has partnered with various retailers — including CVS, Kmart, Rite Aid, 7-Eleven and Walmart — so that you can reload at the register without using cash reload cards (fee of up to $4.95 applies).
Green Dot prepaid debit cards are free when you sign up online, but there is a fee of up to $4.95 when purchased at a retail store. The card’s $5.95 monthly fee is waived when you load at least $1,000 or make 30 purchases per month. Cash withdrawals are free at MoneyPass ATMs, but they cost $2.50 each at all other ATMs.
- Pros: Large cash reload network and access to a large surcharge-free ATM network
- Cons: Relatively high monthly fee (can be waived)
With the Chase Liquid account, you’re getting much of the experience that you would if you had a regular Chase checking account.
You’ll be able to use the bank’s branches, ATMs, online banking and mobile banking channels for free. You won’t be able to do the following: write checks, online bill pay, person-to-person payments and external transfers. However, you will be able to provide your card number to pay bills through a biller’s website. The Chase Liquid card has a flat $4.95 monthly fee. Check and cash deposits and withdrawals are free at all Chase locations. Card purchases don’t have transaction fees.
Generally, you’ll find that it is very close to a checking account with a fixed monthly fee. Unfortunately, you can only apply for it at a Chase branch.
- Pros: Access to many features available with a regular Chase checking account
- Cons: Unavoidable monthly fee
Noteworthy Alternative: American Express Bluebird
Most prepaid debit cards do not allow you to write checks because written checks can lead to overdrafts, which cannot happen on prepaid cards. The American Express Bluebird Account is able to offer check-writing capabilities because written checks must be pre-authorized (funds debited from the account) before they are valid.
The Bluebird Account carries no monthly fee or no activation fee. Funds can be deposited for free by direct deposit, ACH transfer, debit card, mobile check deposit, mailed check deposits and cash load at Walmart. American Express partnered with the MoneyPass ATM network for fee-free withdrawals at 24,000 nationwide ATMs. You can get unlimited free ATM withdrawals at a MoneyPass ATM, as long as you posted a direct deposit within the last 30 days. Otherwise, the fee is $2 per withdrawal (includes non-MoneyPass ATMs). The fee for Bluebird checks is $19.94 for 50 checks or $26.94 for 100 checks, not including shipping and taxes.
If you are a consumer who still relies on paper checks, Bluebird is a great option. It is very similar to American Express Serve, but we think Serve takes a slight edge with its ATM withdrawal policy. See other prepaid debit cards that are worth your consideration.
Note: Prepaid debit cards are not credit cards and they do not help build credit. If you’re looking for something to help improve your credit, view our list of best secured credit cards.
Disclaimer: MyBankTracker was not paid to publish this content, which was not provided, commissioned, reviewed, approved, or endorsed by the company whose products are featured. We may be compensated through an advertiser’s affiliate programs.