How to Determine Your Bank’s Financial Health
You might think all banks are alike and so strictly regulated by the federal government that you never have to worry about the bank failing. But in fact, during the last Great Recession, quite a few did fail.
Between the years 2008 – 2012, 465 banks were closed or sold mostly due to bad real estate loans. And from 2008 through 2016, it is projected that bank failures will cost the federal deposit insurance fund an estimated $98 billion.
It’s true that all deposits up to $250,000 are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), but do you really want to put your money in a bank that’s not healthy? Before you choose a bank based only on a convenient location or interest rates, here are some quick checks you can do to make sure they are healthy enough to weather any financial storms:
- Ensure that the financial institution is FDIC-insured. The FDIC is an independent agency of the federal government that was created in 1933 when thousands of banks failed during the Great Depression. Since that time no depositor has lost a penny of insured funds as a result of a bank failure. It is funded by premiums that banks and thrift institutions pay for deposit insurance coverage and from earnings on investments in U.S. Treasury securities. The FDIC identifies, monitors and addresses any risks to the current $9 trillion in deposited funds and serves to limit the effect on the economy and the financial system when a bank fails.
The standard insurance amount is $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank. You can use the FDIC's Electronic Deposit Insurance Estimator to help you determine if you have adequate deposit insurance for your accounts. Remember that the FDIC does not insure stocks, bonds, mutual funds, annuities or any other investment you might purchase from a bank. Check Deposit Insurance: What's Covered to find out what is and is not protected by FDIC insurance. You will find a chart that lists exactly what is not covered such as the contents of safety deposits boxes and life insurance policies.
Always look for the FDIC logo on a bank’s website, but you may want to look in the FDIC directory to make sure your bank is listed.
- Find out a bank's Texas Ratio. The Texas Ratio is a financial metric used to determine a bank's credit issues. It is calculated by:
non-performing assets and loans, and loans that are 90 days past due
equity capital and loan loss allowance
A ratio of more than 100 is a sign that the bank is at risk. The information for calculating a bank’s Texas Ratio can be found on the FDIC’s website.
- MyBankTracker rates the financial health of every FDIC-insured bank and credit union from “poor” to “excellent,” along with its Texas Ratio. Each bank is given a rating based on financial health, bank fees customer ratings, the number of locations and whether they offer mobile banking. There are also those all-important comments from the past and current customers.
- Look at the percentage of non-current loans compared to total loans. If this percentage is 10% or more, you should be concerned. You can find this information in the bank’s quarterly reports posted on their website or on the FDIC site.
- Look for deposit growth. Deposit growth is good for a bank's balance sheet, and it shows that customers trust the financial institution. You can view the quarterly and annual changes of a bank’s total deposits in their reports or on the FDIC website.
- Look at the bank's available capital, or cash. Strong capital indicates there are more assets to cover any potential losses.
- Search the Federal Reserve website to see which banks have been required to take corrective action in order to avoid financial collapse. These actions might include cease and desist orders, written agreements, prompt directives, removal and prohibition orders, and orders assessing civil money penalties. They may also advise that certain loans be called in or canceled.
The largest bank failure in U.S. history
The largest bank failure in U.S. history occurred in 2008 to Washington Mutual of Seattle. Over $188 billion in deposits were seized by the FDIC, which sold all the company’s assets and liabilities to JPMorgan Chase for a mere $1.9 billion.
The failure was initially caused by mounting losses on mortgages and a plunging stock price, followed by depositors taking out $16.7 billion in just ten days after Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy.
Customers were worried about losing all their money just like many did during the Great Depression. While no one lost their savings, holders of loans and preferred stock saw very little in recovery.
JPMorgan had previously tried to buy WaMu due to their 2,239 retail locations, and some believe no government bailout was offered because the bank’s president had failed to establish a close working relationship with government regulators.
When the FDIC has to come to the rescue
In 1984 Continental Bank, the largest bank in Chicago in assets and deposits and the seventh largest in the U.S., had to be bailed out by the FDIC. The bank was a big participant in oil and gas loans with Penn Square Bank in Oklahoma and experienced large losses when Penn Square failed. Continental’s internal auditors had visited Penn Square in December 1981 and found $565,000 in personal loans from Penn Square to John Lytle, the Continental Bank officer responsible for acquiring the oil and gas loans.
The Continental Bank crisis started on May 8, 1984 when the bank faced a sudden run on its deposits. The run began in Tokyo when a wire story reported rumors that a Japanese bank might acquire Continental Bank. Apparently a translator wrote “disclosure” instead of “rumors,” causing Far Eastern investors holding Continental's certificates of deposit to panic. That day, over $1 billion in Asian money was withdrawn from the bank. Eight days later regulators arranged for a bailout and the FDIC put $4.5 billion in new capital into the bank, assumed liability for the bulk of Continental's bad loans and searched for another bank to take over the institution.
To keep their promise to protect depositors from any losses, the Fed made additional emergency loans to Continental Illinois that rose to $8 billion.
“It was rare, in my observation, for an unpleasant or embarrassing internal audit report to ever make it to top management or to capture their attention if the issues raised could put the brakes on revenue growth,” says Francine McKenna, an internal auditor who worked at Continental during the time of its failure.
Learning from failures
Fortunately, no one with less than $250,000 in deposits lost their money as a result of these or other bank failures. But we can all take away the lesson that there is no such thing as a bank that is “too big to fail,” and auditors and top management do not always know about potential problems until it is too late.
If you do your homework before selecting your next bank, you should not have to worry about any disruptions in service or losing your money.